Excalibur Generator

JIANGSU EXCALIBUR POWER MACHINERY CO., LTD    |   One-stop Power Machinery Manufacturer

NEWS

Table of Contents

How to Choose the Right Size and Power for Your Reversible Plate Compactor

How to Choose the Right Size and Power for Your Reversible Plate Compactor

Picking the right reversible plate compactor is about matching centrifugal force, operating weight, baseplate size, and engine power to the soil type, lift thickness, trench/area dimensions, productivity targets, and site constraints. This guide shows :

  • You need the critical specs that directly affect compaction in practice.
  • A step-by-step sizing method with a worked example.
  • Reference tables mapping soil types → force ranges → lift thickness.
  • Productivity, fuel, and ROI calculators for bids and rentals.
  • What “power” really means (and how much you actually need).

What “right size” Really Means

Reversible plate compactors fill the gap between forward plates and small rollers. They deliver high compaction energy with bidirectional travel, letting operators compact in tight spaces and trenches without turning the machine. “Right size” means a model that:

  • Achieves target density (Proctor/modified Proctor or plate load objectives) for your soil type and lift thickness.
  • Fits the geometry (trench width, slab edges, around structures) and site logistics (ramps, crane picks, doorways).
  • Meets productivity targets (m²/hr or linear meters/hr).
  • Balances engine power, weight, and plate area for efficient energy transfer—not just high paper specs.

The Specs that Matter

Centrifugal force (kN)

Primary driver of compaction energy—the dynamic force generated by the exciter(s). More isn’t always better; too much force in thin lifts or on granular surfaces can cause over-vibration, particle migration, or surface heave.

Operating weight (kg)

Mass helps transmit force and reduce recoil. Heavier plates generally compact deeper lifts, but weight must be balanced with maneuverability and surface bearing limits.

Baseplate size (W×L, mm)

Determines contact pressure and footprint stability. Larger plates spread force over a bigger area (better surface finish, fewer “waves”), but lower contact pressure if force doesn’t scale with area.

Vibration frequency (Hz / vpm) and amplitude (mm)

Higher frequency generally benefits granular soils, while higher amplitude helps cohesive or mixed soils. Reversible plates typically run 55–70 Hz (3,300–4,200 vpm) with 1.2–2.2 mm amplitude depending on the class.

Engine power (kW/HP)

Power must be sufficient to drive the exciter at load. Once the exciter requirement is met, extra horsepower adds little unless you increase force or speed. Over-spec’d engines usually waste fuel.

Travel speed and gradeability

Affects cycle time, especially on long passes and ramps. Typical 35–28 m/min forward and low teens m/min reverse for mid/heavy classes.

Model Classes and Typical Specs

Class Typical Force (kN) Operating Weight (kg) Baseplate (mm) Frequency (Hz) Typical Engine (kW) Use Case Highlights
Light Reversible 20–30 80–140 400–500 × 650–700 60–70 3.5–4.5 Pavers, narrow trenches, granular sands with thin lifts
Medium Reversible 35–45 160–250 500–600 × 700–800 55–65 4.8–6.5 General civil works, base course, utilities
Heavy Reversible 50–65 300–420 600–700 × 800–900 55–65 6.5–8.5 Thick lifts, backfill, stabilization layers
Extra-Heavy Reversible 70–90+ 450–600+ 700–850 × 900–1,000 55–60 8.5–11+ Large excavations, subbase deep compaction, rental fleets for broad demand

Soil Type, Lift Thickness, and Force Selection

Lift thickness (the layer compacted in one pass) depends on soil gradation and moisture. Use the table below as a starting point for typical well-managed moisture conditions (near optimum):

Soil type vs recommended force & lift

Soil Type (Unified/General) Example Materials Recommended Force (kN) Typical Lift (mm) Frequency Bias Notes
Clean granular (GW, SW) Crushed rock, well-graded sand 35–55 200–350 Higher freq Very responsive; avoid over-vibration causing particle migration
Granular with fines (GP-GM, SP-SM) Road base with fines 45–70 200–300 Mid freq Balance amplitude and frequency; watch moisture window
Silty sand/gravel (SM, GM) Moist granular mixes 45–65 150–250 Mid freq Sensitive to water content; verify with field test
Lean clay / clayey sand (CL, SC) Cohesive or mixed 50–80 150–220 Lower freq, higher amp Requires energy + controlled passes to avoid pumping
High plasticity clay (CH) Fat clays 65–90+ 120–180 Lower freq, higher amp Often inefficient with plates; consider sheepsfoot/roller if persistent

Choose the Right Size and Model of Reversible Plate Compactor

The sizing method (five steps)

You can turn this into a quick worksheet for your sales team.

Step 1 — Define the job

  • Soil type and moisture window
  • Lift thickness target (mm)
  • Geometry (trench width, area size, clearance)
  • Productivity (m²/hr or linear m/hr)
  • Access/handling constraints (ramps, crane, vehicle limits)

Step 2 — Choose a force band

Use the Soil vs Force table above to pick a kN band aligned with your lift thickness and soil.

Step 3 — Match weight and baseplate

  • Thin lifts + granular → moderate weight, higher frequency, adequate plate area.
  • Thick lifts + cohesive/mixed → heavier mass, higher amplitude, larger baseplate for stability.

Step 4 — Check engine power (sanity check)

Ensure rated engine output supports selected force at working frequency with 10–15% margin. (Most reputable models are balanced; beware of very high kN on small engines.)

Step 5 — Validate with productivity & geometry

  • Plate width should fit trench with 50–100 mm clearance either side.
  • Compute passes, travel speed, and area output to confirm schedule.
  • Plan for reversals (reversible plates shine in trench confines).

Worked Example: Utility Trench Backfill

Scenario

  • Soil: well-graded sand with fines (SP-SM)
  • Target lift: 220 mm
  • Trench: 700 mm internal width, long runs
  • Daily target: 1,800 m linear trench (single lift)
  • Access via site ramps up to 20% grade

Step 1–2: Force band

SP-SM at 220 mm lift → 45–65 kN recommended.

Step 3: Weight & plate

Pick Heavy Reversible (~50–60 kN, 300–380 kg, 600–700 mm wide plate). Plate width ~600–650 mm leaves ~25–50 mm per side—ideal.

Step 4: Engine sanity

A 7–8 kW engine is typical here; adequate for ~55 kN plates.

Step 5: Productivity

Assume effective forward speed 30 m/min and reverse 12 m/min with reversing every 10 m.

  • Net cycle speed (allowing reversals & overlaps): ~22–24 m/min
  • Pass width: 0.62 m effective
  • Linear productivity: ~1,300–1,450 m/hr per pass (theoretical).
  • Accounting for staging, checks, and lift management, use 30–35% efficiency factor:
    ~450 m/hr realistic → 4 hrs for 1,800 m (single lift) with one machine and an experienced operator.

Productivity Planning Tables

Area productivity (rule-of-thumb)

Use this to sanity-check bids.

Model Class Effective Plate Width (m) Typical Net Speed (m/min) Planning Efficiency* Practical m²/hr
Light 0.45 28 0.30 ~380
Medium 0.55 26 0.35 ~500
Heavy 0.65 24 0.40 ~620
Extra-Heavy 0.75 22 0.40 ~660

Linear productivity (trenches)

Model Class Effective Width (m) Net Speed (m/min) Efficiency Practical m/hr
Light 0.40 30 0.30 ~360
Medium 0.50 28 0.35 ~590
Heavy 0.62 24 0.40 ~595
Extra-Heavy 0.72 20 0.40 ~575

Matching Force, Weight, Frequency, and Amplitude

Recommended envelopes by application

Application Preferred Force (kN) Weight (kg) Frequency (Hz) Amplitude (mm) Notes
Pavers & patios 20–30 90–140 60–70 1.2–1.6 Avoid scuffing; use pad kits
Road base granular 45–65 200–420 55–65 1.6–2.0 General civil, fast production
Mixed soils (SM/SC) 50–80 300–500 55–60 1.8–2.2 Balance amplitude & frequency
Cohesive backfill 65–90 400–600 55–60 1.8–2.2 Watch moisture; reduce lift if pumping

Engine Power: How Much is “enough”?

Exciters convert engine power into vibration. Most mid/heavy reversible plates do not operate power-limited; they are force-limited by exciter design. A practical sanity check:

  • Light (20–30 kN): 3.5–4.5 kW
  • Medium (35–45 kN): 4.8–6.5 kW
  • Heavy (50–65 kN): 6.5–8.5 kW
  • Extra-Heavy (70–90 kN): 8.5–11+ kW

Going far above these bands does not improve density unless your plate/exciter and mass are also scaled. Prioritize reliability, fuel curve, and service network over raw horsepower bragging rights.

Baseplate Geometry and Surface Finish

  • Longer plates help flatten the surface (fewer ripples), especially on granular base courses.
  • Wider plates reduce passes on large areas, but verify contact pressure remains adequate (kN per cm²).
  • Edge radius and steel grade influence glide and wear. Induction-hardened or abrasion-resistant steels extend life on crushed aggregates.

Practical Constraints that Change Your Pick

Constraint Impact Sizing Guidance
Trench only 600–650 mm wide Caps plate width Consider 450–600 mm plate; keep 25–50 mm clearance per side
Frequent ramps (15–20%) Needs torque and traction Favor heavier class with robust reverse torque; check gradeability
Compaction near structures Vibration limits Use lower amplitude / rubber buffers; more passes instead of higher force
Crane/vehicle limit 350 kg Weight cap Top-end medium or light-heavy hybrid
Noise/vibration limits Community rules Select lower frequency or enclosed engine; schedule working windows

Fuel, Cost, and ROI Planning

Fuel consumption estimator

A quick planning tool (typical modern engines):

Class Engine (kW) Load Factor (avg) Fuel Use (L/hr, gasoline) Fuel Use (L/hr, diesel)
Light 4.0 0.55 ~1.1 ~0.9
Medium 6.0 0.60 ~1.6 ~1.3
Heavy 8.0 0.65 ~2.1 ~1.7
Extra-Heavy 10.0 0.70 ~2.7 ~2.2

Ownership vs rental rough cut

Parameter Light Medium Heavy
Typical Purchase (USD) 2,800–4,200 4,500–7,800 7,500–12,500
Typical Day Rate (USD) 60–85 85–120 120–180
Break-Even Days (≈) 45–55 50–75 60–85

If you run >80 rental-equivalent days/year, ownership makes economic sense—assuming you have storage and maintenance capability.

Field Verification Protocol (keep it simple)

Set moisture within OMC ±2%.

Trial strip: compact a 5 m × plate-width section at your planned passes.

Measure density (nuclear gauge or sand cone) or plate load if required.

If below target:

  • Increase passes; if still low, reduce lift or step up force class.
  • Check for over-wet or over-dry; adjust moisture.

Document settings (passes, speed, moisture) and repeat per change in soil/lift.

Safety and Ergonomics Still Matter

Hand-arm vibration (HAV) control via isolated handles saves operators on long shifts.

Reversing response should be smooth and predictable (hydraulic/mechanical control quality matters).

Guarding & tie-downs for transport; dead-man controls where required by local regulation.

Provide hearing protection guidance; reversible plates in confined spaces can exceed safe dBA.

Putting it All Together—Decision Matrix

Use this matrix to jump to a model class quickly, then fine-tune with the previous sections.

Primary Need Soil Lift (mm) Trench/Area Geometry Suggested Class Why
Fast base course on roads GW/SW 220–300 Open areas Heavy (50–65 kN) Balanced force/weight for deep granular lifts
Utility backfill, long runs SP-SM 180–250 650–750 mm trenches Heavy or Medium-Heavy Plate width fits, torque for reversals
Landscaping/pavers Sand/Bedding 80–120 Tight edges Light (20–30 kN) High frequency, gentle amplitude, optional pad
Mixed soils on subdivisions SM/SC 150–220 Mixed geometry 50–70 kN Versatility across moisture changes
Cohesive zones (seasonal) CL/CH 120–180 Confined 65–90 kN (verify) Energy + passes; monitor moisture; consider rollers if slow

Common Sizing Mistakes

Chasing kN numbers without mass/plate to back it up → unstable, bouncy compaction.

Over-wide plates for narrow trenches → wasted passes due to edge losses and scuffing.

Too thick lifts chasing production → density fails, rework.

Ignoring moisture → energy wasted regardless of machine size.

Oversized engine on undersized exciter → fuel penalty with no density gain.

Underestimating reversals & overlaps → schedule slips; plan with realistic efficiency factors.

Scroll to Top

We'd Love to Hear From You​.
Please call us!

Get In Touch With Us Now